Development of a chest wall protector effective in preventing sudden cardiac death by chest wall impact (Commotio Cordis)

Kartik Kumar, Swati N. Mandleywala, Michael P. Gannon, Nathan Anthony Mark Estes, Jonathan Weinstock, Mark S. Link

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: Commotio cordis, sudden death with chest impact, occurs clinically despite chest wall protectors worn in sports. In an experimental model of commotio cordis, commercially available chest wall protectors failed to prevent ventricular fibrillation (VF). The goal of the current investigation was to develop a chest wall protector effective in the prevention of commotio cordis. Design: In the Tufts experimental model of commotio cordis the ability of chest protectors to prevent VF was assessed. Impacts were delivered with a 40-mph lacrosse ball, timed to the vulnerable period for VF. Intervention: A chest wall protector or no chest wall protector (control) was randomly assigned to be placed over the chest. Four iterative series of 2 to 4 different chest wall material combinations were assessed. Materials included 3 different foams (Accelleron [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell high density foam; Airilon [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell low density soft foam; and an open cell memory foam) that were adhered to a layer of TriDur (Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA), a flexible elastomeric coated aramid that was bonded to a semirigid polypropylene polymer (ImpacShield, Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA). Main Outcome Measure: Induction of VF by chest wall impact was the primary outcome. Results: Of 80 impacts without chest protectors, 43 (54%) resulted in VF. Ventricular fibrillation with chest protectors ranged from a high of 60% to a low of 5%. Of 12 chest protectors assessed, only 3 significantly lowered the risk of VF compared with impacts without chest protectors. These 3 chest protectors were combinations of Accelleron, Airilon, TriDur, and ImpacShield of different thicknesses. Protection increased linearly with the thicker combinations. Conclusions: Effective protection against VF with chest wall protection can be achieved in an experimental model of commotio cordis. Clinical Relevance: Chest protector designs incorporating these novel materials will likely be effective in the prevention of commotio cordis on the playing field.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)26-30
Number of pages5
JournalClinical Journal of Sport Medicine
Volume27
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2017

Fingerprint

Commotio Cordis
Sudden Cardiac Death
Thoracic Wall
Ventricular Fibrillation
Thorax
Technology
Theoretical Models
Cell Count
Racquet Sports
Foam Cells
Polypropylenes
Sudden Death
Sports
Polymers

Keywords

  • athlete
  • chest protectors
  • Commotio cordis
  • sudden cardiac death
  • ventricular fibrillation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
  • Physical Therapy, Sports Therapy and Rehabilitation

Cite this

Development of a chest wall protector effective in preventing sudden cardiac death by chest wall impact (Commotio Cordis). / Kumar, Kartik; Mandleywala, Swati N.; Gannon, Michael P.; Mark Estes, Nathan Anthony; Weinstock, Jonathan; Link, Mark S.

In: Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine, Vol. 27, No. 1, 01.01.2017, p. 26-30.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kumar, Kartik ; Mandleywala, Swati N. ; Gannon, Michael P. ; Mark Estes, Nathan Anthony ; Weinstock, Jonathan ; Link, Mark S. / Development of a chest wall protector effective in preventing sudden cardiac death by chest wall impact (Commotio Cordis). In: Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. 2017 ; Vol. 27, No. 1. pp. 26-30.
@article{3a64a678928d4f5aa8352dbb2061c6aa,
title = "Development of a chest wall protector effective in preventing sudden cardiac death by chest wall impact (Commotio Cordis)",
abstract = "Objective: Commotio cordis, sudden death with chest impact, occurs clinically despite chest wall protectors worn in sports. In an experimental model of commotio cordis, commercially available chest wall protectors failed to prevent ventricular fibrillation (VF). The goal of the current investigation was to develop a chest wall protector effective in the prevention of commotio cordis. Design: In the Tufts experimental model of commotio cordis the ability of chest protectors to prevent VF was assessed. Impacts were delivered with a 40-mph lacrosse ball, timed to the vulnerable period for VF. Intervention: A chest wall protector or no chest wall protector (control) was randomly assigned to be placed over the chest. Four iterative series of 2 to 4 different chest wall material combinations were assessed. Materials included 3 different foams (Accelleron [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell high density foam; Airilon [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell low density soft foam; and an open cell memory foam) that were adhered to a layer of TriDur (Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA), a flexible elastomeric coated aramid that was bonded to a semirigid polypropylene polymer (ImpacShield, Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA). Main Outcome Measure: Induction of VF by chest wall impact was the primary outcome. Results: Of 80 impacts without chest protectors, 43 (54{\%}) resulted in VF. Ventricular fibrillation with chest protectors ranged from a high of 60{\%} to a low of 5{\%}. Of 12 chest protectors assessed, only 3 significantly lowered the risk of VF compared with impacts without chest protectors. These 3 chest protectors were combinations of Accelleron, Airilon, TriDur, and ImpacShield of different thicknesses. Protection increased linearly with the thicker combinations. Conclusions: Effective protection against VF with chest wall protection can be achieved in an experimental model of commotio cordis. Clinical Relevance: Chest protector designs incorporating these novel materials will likely be effective in the prevention of commotio cordis on the playing field.",
keywords = "athlete, chest protectors, Commotio cordis, sudden cardiac death, ventricular fibrillation",
author = "Kartik Kumar and Mandleywala, {Swati N.} and Gannon, {Michael P.} and {Mark Estes}, {Nathan Anthony} and Jonathan Weinstock and Link, {Mark S.}",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1097/JSM.0000000000000297",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "27",
pages = "26--30",
journal = "Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine",
issn = "1050-642X",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Development of a chest wall protector effective in preventing sudden cardiac death by chest wall impact (Commotio Cordis)

AU - Kumar, Kartik

AU - Mandleywala, Swati N.

AU - Gannon, Michael P.

AU - Mark Estes, Nathan Anthony

AU - Weinstock, Jonathan

AU - Link, Mark S.

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Objective: Commotio cordis, sudden death with chest impact, occurs clinically despite chest wall protectors worn in sports. In an experimental model of commotio cordis, commercially available chest wall protectors failed to prevent ventricular fibrillation (VF). The goal of the current investigation was to develop a chest wall protector effective in the prevention of commotio cordis. Design: In the Tufts experimental model of commotio cordis the ability of chest protectors to prevent VF was assessed. Impacts were delivered with a 40-mph lacrosse ball, timed to the vulnerable period for VF. Intervention: A chest wall protector or no chest wall protector (control) was randomly assigned to be placed over the chest. Four iterative series of 2 to 4 different chest wall material combinations were assessed. Materials included 3 different foams (Accelleron [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell high density foam; Airilon [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell low density soft foam; and an open cell memory foam) that were adhered to a layer of TriDur (Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA), a flexible elastomeric coated aramid that was bonded to a semirigid polypropylene polymer (ImpacShield, Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA). Main Outcome Measure: Induction of VF by chest wall impact was the primary outcome. Results: Of 80 impacts without chest protectors, 43 (54%) resulted in VF. Ventricular fibrillation with chest protectors ranged from a high of 60% to a low of 5%. Of 12 chest protectors assessed, only 3 significantly lowered the risk of VF compared with impacts without chest protectors. These 3 chest protectors were combinations of Accelleron, Airilon, TriDur, and ImpacShield of different thicknesses. Protection increased linearly with the thicker combinations. Conclusions: Effective protection against VF with chest wall protection can be achieved in an experimental model of commotio cordis. Clinical Relevance: Chest protector designs incorporating these novel materials will likely be effective in the prevention of commotio cordis on the playing field.

AB - Objective: Commotio cordis, sudden death with chest impact, occurs clinically despite chest wall protectors worn in sports. In an experimental model of commotio cordis, commercially available chest wall protectors failed to prevent ventricular fibrillation (VF). The goal of the current investigation was to develop a chest wall protector effective in the prevention of commotio cordis. Design: In the Tufts experimental model of commotio cordis the ability of chest protectors to prevent VF was assessed. Impacts were delivered with a 40-mph lacrosse ball, timed to the vulnerable period for VF. Intervention: A chest wall protector or no chest wall protector (control) was randomly assigned to be placed over the chest. Four iterative series of 2 to 4 different chest wall material combinations were assessed. Materials included 3 different foams (Accelleron [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell high density foam; Airilon [Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA], closed cell low density soft foam; and an open cell memory foam) that were adhered to a layer of TriDur (Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA), a flexible elastomeric coated aramid that was bonded to a semirigid polypropylene polymer (ImpacShield, Unequal Technologies, Glen Mills, PA). Main Outcome Measure: Induction of VF by chest wall impact was the primary outcome. Results: Of 80 impacts without chest protectors, 43 (54%) resulted in VF. Ventricular fibrillation with chest protectors ranged from a high of 60% to a low of 5%. Of 12 chest protectors assessed, only 3 significantly lowered the risk of VF compared with impacts without chest protectors. These 3 chest protectors were combinations of Accelleron, Airilon, TriDur, and ImpacShield of different thicknesses. Protection increased linearly with the thicker combinations. Conclusions: Effective protection against VF with chest wall protection can be achieved in an experimental model of commotio cordis. Clinical Relevance: Chest protector designs incorporating these novel materials will likely be effective in the prevention of commotio cordis on the playing field.

KW - athlete

KW - chest protectors

KW - Commotio cordis

KW - sudden cardiac death

KW - ventricular fibrillation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84961620936&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84961620936&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/JSM.0000000000000297

DO - 10.1097/JSM.0000000000000297

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 26

EP - 30

JO - Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine

JF - Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine

SN - 1050-642X

IS - 1

ER -