Estimating organ doses from tube current modulated CT examinations using a generalized linear model

Maryam Bostani, Kyle McMillan, Peiyun Lu, Grace Hyun J. Kim, Dianna Cody, Gary Arbique, S. Bruce Greenberg, John J. DeMarco, Chris H. Cagnon, Michael F. McNitt-Gray

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

PURPOSE: Currently, available Computed Tomography dose metrics are mostly based on fixed tube current Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and/or physical measurements such as the size specific dose estimate (SSDE). In addition to not being able to account for Tube Current Modulation (TCM), these dose metrics do not represent actual patient dose. The purpose of this study was to generate and evaluate a dose estimation model based on the Generalized Linear Model (GLM), which extends the ability to estimate organ dose from tube current modulated examinations by incorporating regional descriptors of patient size, scanner output, and other scan-specific variables as needed.

METHODS: The collection of a total of 332 patient CT scans at four different institutions was approved by each institution's IRB and used to generate and test organ dose estimation models. The patient population consisted of pediatric and adult patients and included thoracic and abdomen/pelvis scans. The scans were performed on three different CT scanner systems. Manual segmentation of organs, depending on the examined anatomy, was performed on each patient's image series. In addition to the collected images, detailed TCM data were collected for all patients scanned on Siemens CT scanners, while for all GE and Toshiba patients, data representing z-axis-only TCM, extracted from the DICOM header of the images, were used for TCM simulations. A validated MC dosimetry package was used to perform detailed simulation of CT examinations on all 332 patient models to estimate dose to each segmented organ (lungs, breasts, liver, spleen, and kidneys), denoted as reference organ dose values. Approximately 60% of the data were used to train a dose estimation model, while the remaining 40% was used to evaluate performance. Two different methodologies were explored using GLM to generate a dose estimation model: (a) using the conventional exponential relationship between normalized organ dose and size with regional water equivalent diameter (WED) and regional CTDIvol as variables and (b) using the same exponential relationship with the addition of categorical variables such as scanner model and organ to provide a more complete estimate of factors that may affect organ dose. Finally, estimates from generated models were compared to those obtained from SSDE and ImPACT.

RESULTS: The Generalized Linear Model yielded organ dose estimates that were significantly closer to the MC reference organ dose values than were organ doses estimated via SSDE or ImPACT. Moreover, the GLM estimates were better than those of SSDE or ImPACT irrespective of whether or not categorical variables were used in the model. While the improvement associated with a categorical variable was substantial in estimating breast dose, the improvement was minor for other organs.

CONCLUSIONS: The GLM approach extends the current CT dose estimation methods by allowing the use of additional variables to more accurately estimate organ dose from TCM scans. Thus, this approach may be able to overcome the limitations of current CT dose metrics to provide more accurate estimates of patient dose, in particular, dose to organs with considerable variability across the population.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1500-1513
Number of pages14
JournalMedical Physics
Volume44
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1 2017

Fingerprint

Linear Models
Breast
Organ Size
Research Ethics Committees
Pelvis
Abdomen
Population
Anatomy
Thorax
Spleen
Tomography
Pediatrics
Kidney
Lung
Water
Liver

Keywords

  • CT
  • generalized linear model
  • Monte Carlo simulations
  • organ dose estimation
  • tube current modulation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biophysics
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Bostani, M., McMillan, K., Lu, P., Kim, G. H. J., Cody, D., Arbique, G., ... McNitt-Gray, M. F. (2017). Estimating organ doses from tube current modulated CT examinations using a generalized linear model. Medical Physics, 44(4), 1500-1513. https://doi.org/10.1002/mp.12119

Estimating organ doses from tube current modulated CT examinations using a generalized linear model. / Bostani, Maryam; McMillan, Kyle; Lu, Peiyun; Kim, Grace Hyun J.; Cody, Dianna; Arbique, Gary; Greenberg, S. Bruce; DeMarco, John J.; Cagnon, Chris H.; McNitt-Gray, Michael F.

In: Medical Physics, Vol. 44, No. 4, 01.04.2017, p. 1500-1513.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bostani, M, McMillan, K, Lu, P, Kim, GHJ, Cody, D, Arbique, G, Greenberg, SB, DeMarco, JJ, Cagnon, CH & McNitt-Gray, MF 2017, 'Estimating organ doses from tube current modulated CT examinations using a generalized linear model', Medical Physics, vol. 44, no. 4, pp. 1500-1513. https://doi.org/10.1002/mp.12119
Bostani, Maryam ; McMillan, Kyle ; Lu, Peiyun ; Kim, Grace Hyun J. ; Cody, Dianna ; Arbique, Gary ; Greenberg, S. Bruce ; DeMarco, John J. ; Cagnon, Chris H. ; McNitt-Gray, Michael F. / Estimating organ doses from tube current modulated CT examinations using a generalized linear model. In: Medical Physics. 2017 ; Vol. 44, No. 4. pp. 1500-1513.
@article{0163a502d43943d7b1fdc9ee85b1472e,
title = "Estimating organ doses from tube current modulated CT examinations using a generalized linear model",
abstract = "PURPOSE: Currently, available Computed Tomography dose metrics are mostly based on fixed tube current Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and/or physical measurements such as the size specific dose estimate (SSDE). In addition to not being able to account for Tube Current Modulation (TCM), these dose metrics do not represent actual patient dose. The purpose of this study was to generate and evaluate a dose estimation model based on the Generalized Linear Model (GLM), which extends the ability to estimate organ dose from tube current modulated examinations by incorporating regional descriptors of patient size, scanner output, and other scan-specific variables as needed.METHODS: The collection of a total of 332 patient CT scans at four different institutions was approved by each institution's IRB and used to generate and test organ dose estimation models. The patient population consisted of pediatric and adult patients and included thoracic and abdomen/pelvis scans. The scans were performed on three different CT scanner systems. Manual segmentation of organs, depending on the examined anatomy, was performed on each patient's image series. In addition to the collected images, detailed TCM data were collected for all patients scanned on Siemens CT scanners, while for all GE and Toshiba patients, data representing z-axis-only TCM, extracted from the DICOM header of the images, were used for TCM simulations. A validated MC dosimetry package was used to perform detailed simulation of CT examinations on all 332 patient models to estimate dose to each segmented organ (lungs, breasts, liver, spleen, and kidneys), denoted as reference organ dose values. Approximately 60{\%} of the data were used to train a dose estimation model, while the remaining 40{\%} was used to evaluate performance. Two different methodologies were explored using GLM to generate a dose estimation model: (a) using the conventional exponential relationship between normalized organ dose and size with regional water equivalent diameter (WED) and regional CTDIvol as variables and (b) using the same exponential relationship with the addition of categorical variables such as scanner model and organ to provide a more complete estimate of factors that may affect organ dose. Finally, estimates from generated models were compared to those obtained from SSDE and ImPACT.RESULTS: The Generalized Linear Model yielded organ dose estimates that were significantly closer to the MC reference organ dose values than were organ doses estimated via SSDE or ImPACT. Moreover, the GLM estimates were better than those of SSDE or ImPACT irrespective of whether or not categorical variables were used in the model. While the improvement associated with a categorical variable was substantial in estimating breast dose, the improvement was minor for other organs.CONCLUSIONS: The GLM approach extends the current CT dose estimation methods by allowing the use of additional variables to more accurately estimate organ dose from TCM scans. Thus, this approach may be able to overcome the limitations of current CT dose metrics to provide more accurate estimates of patient dose, in particular, dose to organs with considerable variability across the population.",
keywords = "CT, generalized linear model, Monte Carlo simulations, organ dose estimation, tube current modulation",
author = "Maryam Bostani and Kyle McMillan and Peiyun Lu and Kim, {Grace Hyun J.} and Dianna Cody and Gary Arbique and Greenberg, {S. Bruce} and DeMarco, {John J.} and Cagnon, {Chris H.} and McNitt-Gray, {Michael F.}",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/mp.12119",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "44",
pages = "1500--1513",
journal = "Medical Physics",
issn = "0094-2405",
publisher = "AAPM - American Association of Physicists in Medicine",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Estimating organ doses from tube current modulated CT examinations using a generalized linear model

AU - Bostani, Maryam

AU - McMillan, Kyle

AU - Lu, Peiyun

AU - Kim, Grace Hyun J.

AU - Cody, Dianna

AU - Arbique, Gary

AU - Greenberg, S. Bruce

AU - DeMarco, John J.

AU - Cagnon, Chris H.

AU - McNitt-Gray, Michael F.

PY - 2017/4/1

Y1 - 2017/4/1

N2 - PURPOSE: Currently, available Computed Tomography dose metrics are mostly based on fixed tube current Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and/or physical measurements such as the size specific dose estimate (SSDE). In addition to not being able to account for Tube Current Modulation (TCM), these dose metrics do not represent actual patient dose. The purpose of this study was to generate and evaluate a dose estimation model based on the Generalized Linear Model (GLM), which extends the ability to estimate organ dose from tube current modulated examinations by incorporating regional descriptors of patient size, scanner output, and other scan-specific variables as needed.METHODS: The collection of a total of 332 patient CT scans at four different institutions was approved by each institution's IRB and used to generate and test organ dose estimation models. The patient population consisted of pediatric and adult patients and included thoracic and abdomen/pelvis scans. The scans were performed on three different CT scanner systems. Manual segmentation of organs, depending on the examined anatomy, was performed on each patient's image series. In addition to the collected images, detailed TCM data were collected for all patients scanned on Siemens CT scanners, while for all GE and Toshiba patients, data representing z-axis-only TCM, extracted from the DICOM header of the images, were used for TCM simulations. A validated MC dosimetry package was used to perform detailed simulation of CT examinations on all 332 patient models to estimate dose to each segmented organ (lungs, breasts, liver, spleen, and kidneys), denoted as reference organ dose values. Approximately 60% of the data were used to train a dose estimation model, while the remaining 40% was used to evaluate performance. Two different methodologies were explored using GLM to generate a dose estimation model: (a) using the conventional exponential relationship between normalized organ dose and size with regional water equivalent diameter (WED) and regional CTDIvol as variables and (b) using the same exponential relationship with the addition of categorical variables such as scanner model and organ to provide a more complete estimate of factors that may affect organ dose. Finally, estimates from generated models were compared to those obtained from SSDE and ImPACT.RESULTS: The Generalized Linear Model yielded organ dose estimates that were significantly closer to the MC reference organ dose values than were organ doses estimated via SSDE or ImPACT. Moreover, the GLM estimates were better than those of SSDE or ImPACT irrespective of whether or not categorical variables were used in the model. While the improvement associated with a categorical variable was substantial in estimating breast dose, the improvement was minor for other organs.CONCLUSIONS: The GLM approach extends the current CT dose estimation methods by allowing the use of additional variables to more accurately estimate organ dose from TCM scans. Thus, this approach may be able to overcome the limitations of current CT dose metrics to provide more accurate estimates of patient dose, in particular, dose to organs with considerable variability across the population.

AB - PURPOSE: Currently, available Computed Tomography dose metrics are mostly based on fixed tube current Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and/or physical measurements such as the size specific dose estimate (SSDE). In addition to not being able to account for Tube Current Modulation (TCM), these dose metrics do not represent actual patient dose. The purpose of this study was to generate and evaluate a dose estimation model based on the Generalized Linear Model (GLM), which extends the ability to estimate organ dose from tube current modulated examinations by incorporating regional descriptors of patient size, scanner output, and other scan-specific variables as needed.METHODS: The collection of a total of 332 patient CT scans at four different institutions was approved by each institution's IRB and used to generate and test organ dose estimation models. The patient population consisted of pediatric and adult patients and included thoracic and abdomen/pelvis scans. The scans were performed on three different CT scanner systems. Manual segmentation of organs, depending on the examined anatomy, was performed on each patient's image series. In addition to the collected images, detailed TCM data were collected for all patients scanned on Siemens CT scanners, while for all GE and Toshiba patients, data representing z-axis-only TCM, extracted from the DICOM header of the images, were used for TCM simulations. A validated MC dosimetry package was used to perform detailed simulation of CT examinations on all 332 patient models to estimate dose to each segmented organ (lungs, breasts, liver, spleen, and kidneys), denoted as reference organ dose values. Approximately 60% of the data were used to train a dose estimation model, while the remaining 40% was used to evaluate performance. Two different methodologies were explored using GLM to generate a dose estimation model: (a) using the conventional exponential relationship between normalized organ dose and size with regional water equivalent diameter (WED) and regional CTDIvol as variables and (b) using the same exponential relationship with the addition of categorical variables such as scanner model and organ to provide a more complete estimate of factors that may affect organ dose. Finally, estimates from generated models were compared to those obtained from SSDE and ImPACT.RESULTS: The Generalized Linear Model yielded organ dose estimates that were significantly closer to the MC reference organ dose values than were organ doses estimated via SSDE or ImPACT. Moreover, the GLM estimates were better than those of SSDE or ImPACT irrespective of whether or not categorical variables were used in the model. While the improvement associated with a categorical variable was substantial in estimating breast dose, the improvement was minor for other organs.CONCLUSIONS: The GLM approach extends the current CT dose estimation methods by allowing the use of additional variables to more accurately estimate organ dose from TCM scans. Thus, this approach may be able to overcome the limitations of current CT dose metrics to provide more accurate estimates of patient dose, in particular, dose to organs with considerable variability across the population.

KW - CT

KW - generalized linear model

KW - Monte Carlo simulations

KW - organ dose estimation

KW - tube current modulation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85021308852&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85021308852&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/mp.12119

DO - 10.1002/mp.12119

M3 - Article

C2 - 28112399

AN - SCOPUS:85021308852

VL - 44

SP - 1500

EP - 1513

JO - Medical Physics

JF - Medical Physics

SN - 0094-2405

IS - 4

ER -