Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays

Jillian E. Urban, William C. Flood, Barret J. Zimmerman, Mireille E. Kelley, Mark A. Espeland, Liam McNamara, Elizabeth M. Davenport, Alexander K. Powers, Christopher T. Whitlow, Joseph A. Maldjian, Joel D. Stitzel

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

OBJECTIVE There is a growing body of literature informing efforts to improve the safety of football; however, research relating on-field activity to head impacts in youth football is limited. Therefore, the objective of this study was to compare head impact exposure (HIE) measured in game plays among 3 youth football teams. METHODS Head impact and video data were collected from athletes (ages 10–13 years) participating on 3 youth football teams. Video analysis was performed to verify head impacts and assign each to a specific play type. Each play was categorized as a down, punt, kickoff, field goal, or false start. Kickoffs and punts were classified as special teams. Downs were classified as running, passing, or other. HIE was quantified by play type in terms of mean, median, and 95th percentile linear and rotational acceleration. Mixed-effects models were used to assess differences in acceleration among play types. Contact occurring on special teams plays was evaluated using a standardized video abstraction form. RESULTS A total of 3003 head impacts over 27.5 games were analyzed and paired with detailed video coding of plays. Most head impacts were attributed to running (79.6%), followed by passing (14.0%), and special teams (6.4%) plays. The 95th percentile linear acceleration measured during each play type was 52.6g, 50.7g, and 65.5g, respectively. Special teams had significantly greater mean linear acceleration than running and passing plays (both p = 0.03). The most common kick result on special teams was a deep kick, of which 85% were attempted to be returned. No special teams plays resulted in a touchback, and one resulted in a fair catch. One-third of all special teams plays and 92% of all nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. CONCLUSIONS The results demonstrate a trend toward higher head impact magnitudes on special teams than for running and passing plays, but a greater number of impacts were measured during running plays. Deep kicks were most common on special teams, and many returned and nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. These results support policy changes to youth special teams plays, including modifying the yard line the ball is kicked from and coaching proper return technique. Further investigation into biomechanical exposure measured during game impact scenarios is needed to inform policy relevant to the youth level.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)190-199
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Neurosurgery: Pediatrics
Volume24
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Football
Head
Running
Athletes
Diving
Safety
Research

Keywords

  • Biomechanics
  • Football
  • Head acceleration
  • Head impacts
  • Injury
  • Pediatrics
  • Trauma

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery
  • Pediatrics, Perinatology, and Child Health
  • Clinical Neurology

Cite this

Urban, J. E., Flood, W. C., Zimmerman, B. J., Kelley, M. E., Espeland, M. A., McNamara, L., ... Stitzel, J. D. (2019). Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays. Journal of Neurosurgery: Pediatrics, 24(2), 190-199. https://doi.org/10.3171/2019.2.PEDS18558

Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays. / Urban, Jillian E.; Flood, William C.; Zimmerman, Barret J.; Kelley, Mireille E.; Espeland, Mark A.; McNamara, Liam; Davenport, Elizabeth M.; Powers, Alexander K.; Whitlow, Christopher T.; Maldjian, Joseph A.; Stitzel, Joel D.

In: Journal of Neurosurgery: Pediatrics, Vol. 24, No. 2, 01.01.2019, p. 190-199.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Urban, JE, Flood, WC, Zimmerman, BJ, Kelley, ME, Espeland, MA, McNamara, L, Davenport, EM, Powers, AK, Whitlow, CT, Maldjian, JA & Stitzel, JD 2019, 'Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays', Journal of Neurosurgery: Pediatrics, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 190-199. https://doi.org/10.3171/2019.2.PEDS18558
Urban JE, Flood WC, Zimmerman BJ, Kelley ME, Espeland MA, McNamara L et al. Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays. Journal of Neurosurgery: Pediatrics. 2019 Jan 1;24(2):190-199. https://doi.org/10.3171/2019.2.PEDS18558
Urban, Jillian E. ; Flood, William C. ; Zimmerman, Barret J. ; Kelley, Mireille E. ; Espeland, Mark A. ; McNamara, Liam ; Davenport, Elizabeth M. ; Powers, Alexander K. ; Whitlow, Christopher T. ; Maldjian, Joseph A. ; Stitzel, Joel D. / Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays. In: Journal of Neurosurgery: Pediatrics. 2019 ; Vol. 24, No. 2. pp. 190-199.
@article{1339ae5431ff467a917c35d842e147c1,
title = "Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays",
abstract = "OBJECTIVE There is a growing body of literature informing efforts to improve the safety of football; however, research relating on-field activity to head impacts in youth football is limited. Therefore, the objective of this study was to compare head impact exposure (HIE) measured in game plays among 3 youth football teams. METHODS Head impact and video data were collected from athletes (ages 10–13 years) participating on 3 youth football teams. Video analysis was performed to verify head impacts and assign each to a specific play type. Each play was categorized as a down, punt, kickoff, field goal, or false start. Kickoffs and punts were classified as special teams. Downs were classified as running, passing, or other. HIE was quantified by play type in terms of mean, median, and 95th percentile linear and rotational acceleration. Mixed-effects models were used to assess differences in acceleration among play types. Contact occurring on special teams plays was evaluated using a standardized video abstraction form. RESULTS A total of 3003 head impacts over 27.5 games were analyzed and paired with detailed video coding of plays. Most head impacts were attributed to running (79.6{\%}), followed by passing (14.0{\%}), and special teams (6.4{\%}) plays. The 95th percentile linear acceleration measured during each play type was 52.6g, 50.7g, and 65.5g, respectively. Special teams had significantly greater mean linear acceleration than running and passing plays (both p = 0.03). The most common kick result on special teams was a deep kick, of which 85{\%} were attempted to be returned. No special teams plays resulted in a touchback, and one resulted in a fair catch. One-third of all special teams plays and 92{\%} of all nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. CONCLUSIONS The results demonstrate a trend toward higher head impact magnitudes on special teams than for running and passing plays, but a greater number of impacts were measured during running plays. Deep kicks were most common on special teams, and many returned and nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. These results support policy changes to youth special teams plays, including modifying the yard line the ball is kicked from and coaching proper return technique. Further investigation into biomechanical exposure measured during game impact scenarios is needed to inform policy relevant to the youth level.",
keywords = "Biomechanics, Football, Head acceleration, Head impacts, Injury, Pediatrics, Trauma",
author = "Urban, {Jillian E.} and Flood, {William C.} and Zimmerman, {Barret J.} and Kelley, {Mireille E.} and Espeland, {Mark A.} and Liam McNamara and Davenport, {Elizabeth M.} and Powers, {Alexander K.} and Whitlow, {Christopher T.} and Maldjian, {Joseph A.} and Stitzel, {Joel D.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3171/2019.2.PEDS18558",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "24",
pages = "190--199",
journal = "Journal of neurosurgery. Pediatrics",
issn = "1933-0707",
publisher = "American Association of Neurological Surgeons",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluation of head impact exposure measured from youth football game plays

AU - Urban, Jillian E.

AU - Flood, William C.

AU - Zimmerman, Barret J.

AU - Kelley, Mireille E.

AU - Espeland, Mark A.

AU - McNamara, Liam

AU - Davenport, Elizabeth M.

AU - Powers, Alexander K.

AU - Whitlow, Christopher T.

AU - Maldjian, Joseph A.

AU - Stitzel, Joel D.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - OBJECTIVE There is a growing body of literature informing efforts to improve the safety of football; however, research relating on-field activity to head impacts in youth football is limited. Therefore, the objective of this study was to compare head impact exposure (HIE) measured in game plays among 3 youth football teams. METHODS Head impact and video data were collected from athletes (ages 10–13 years) participating on 3 youth football teams. Video analysis was performed to verify head impacts and assign each to a specific play type. Each play was categorized as a down, punt, kickoff, field goal, or false start. Kickoffs and punts were classified as special teams. Downs were classified as running, passing, or other. HIE was quantified by play type in terms of mean, median, and 95th percentile linear and rotational acceleration. Mixed-effects models were used to assess differences in acceleration among play types. Contact occurring on special teams plays was evaluated using a standardized video abstraction form. RESULTS A total of 3003 head impacts over 27.5 games were analyzed and paired with detailed video coding of plays. Most head impacts were attributed to running (79.6%), followed by passing (14.0%), and special teams (6.4%) plays. The 95th percentile linear acceleration measured during each play type was 52.6g, 50.7g, and 65.5g, respectively. Special teams had significantly greater mean linear acceleration than running and passing plays (both p = 0.03). The most common kick result on special teams was a deep kick, of which 85% were attempted to be returned. No special teams plays resulted in a touchback, and one resulted in a fair catch. One-third of all special teams plays and 92% of all nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. CONCLUSIONS The results demonstrate a trend toward higher head impact magnitudes on special teams than for running and passing plays, but a greater number of impacts were measured during running plays. Deep kicks were most common on special teams, and many returned and nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. These results support policy changes to youth special teams plays, including modifying the yard line the ball is kicked from and coaching proper return technique. Further investigation into biomechanical exposure measured during game impact scenarios is needed to inform policy relevant to the youth level.

AB - OBJECTIVE There is a growing body of literature informing efforts to improve the safety of football; however, research relating on-field activity to head impacts in youth football is limited. Therefore, the objective of this study was to compare head impact exposure (HIE) measured in game plays among 3 youth football teams. METHODS Head impact and video data were collected from athletes (ages 10–13 years) participating on 3 youth football teams. Video analysis was performed to verify head impacts and assign each to a specific play type. Each play was categorized as a down, punt, kickoff, field goal, or false start. Kickoffs and punts were classified as special teams. Downs were classified as running, passing, or other. HIE was quantified by play type in terms of mean, median, and 95th percentile linear and rotational acceleration. Mixed-effects models were used to assess differences in acceleration among play types. Contact occurring on special teams plays was evaluated using a standardized video abstraction form. RESULTS A total of 3003 head impacts over 27.5 games were analyzed and paired with detailed video coding of plays. Most head impacts were attributed to running (79.6%), followed by passing (14.0%), and special teams (6.4%) plays. The 95th percentile linear acceleration measured during each play type was 52.6g, 50.7g, and 65.5g, respectively. Special teams had significantly greater mean linear acceleration than running and passing plays (both p = 0.03). The most common kick result on special teams was a deep kick, of which 85% were attempted to be returned. No special teams plays resulted in a touchback, and one resulted in a fair catch. One-third of all special teams plays and 92% of all nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. CONCLUSIONS The results demonstrate a trend toward higher head impact magnitudes on special teams than for running and passing plays, but a greater number of impacts were measured during running plays. Deep kicks were most common on special teams, and many returned and nonreturned kicks resulted in athletes diving toward the ball. These results support policy changes to youth special teams plays, including modifying the yard line the ball is kicked from and coaching proper return technique. Further investigation into biomechanical exposure measured during game impact scenarios is needed to inform policy relevant to the youth level.

KW - Biomechanics

KW - Football

KW - Head acceleration

KW - Head impacts

KW - Injury

KW - Pediatrics

KW - Trauma

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85073641749&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85073641749&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3171/2019.2.PEDS18558

DO - 10.3171/2019.2.PEDS18558

M3 - Article

C2 - 31075762

AN - SCOPUS:85073641749

VL - 24

SP - 190

EP - 199

JO - Journal of neurosurgery. Pediatrics

JF - Journal of neurosurgery. Pediatrics

SN - 1933-0707

IS - 2

ER -