TY - JOUR
T1 - In search of positive masculine role norms
T2 - Testing the positive psychology positive masculinity paradigm
AU - McDermott, Ryon C.
AU - Pietrantonio, Kipp R.
AU - Browning, Brandon R.
AU - McKelvey, Daniel K.
AU - Jones, Zachary K.
AU - Booth, Nathan R.
AU - Sevig, Todd D.
N1 - Funding Information:
We thank two additional members of the Culture and Individual Differences research team within the Combined-Integrated Clinical and Counseling Psychology PhD program at the University of South Alabama for their help collecting data: Paige Naylor and Lacy Kantra. Portions of the present study were presented as part of a symposium at the 2016 American Psychological Association annual conference in Denver, Colorado.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2018 American Psychological Association.
PY - 2019/1
Y1 - 2019/1
N2 - Researchers using the positive psychology positive masculinity paradigm have advanced several aspects of masculinity that, in theory, represent socialized beliefs linked to healthy personal and relational outcomes in men. However, investigators have yet to explicitly test whether positive masculinity constructs capture broader societal messages dictating positive masculine thoughts, feelings, and behaviors (i.e., male role norms). The present exploratory study created an online survey informed by literature and informal focus groups/interviews to explore how 79 potential positive masculinity attributes were perceived as both positive and socially expected of men. Using Internet and community samples of men and women (N = 1,077), descriptive statistics and paired-sample t tests identified which attributes were rated as positive and statistically expected of men more than they were expected of women. Of the 79 items, all but 3 were strongly rated as positive, 32 were expected more of men, 36 were expected more of women, and 11 were gender neutral. Many definitions of positive masculinity in the extant literature correctly represented thoughts, feelings, and behaviors viewed as positive and socially expected of men, particularly male provider and protector roles. However, some attributes identified as both positive and masculine in the present study may represent moderate expressions of traditional masculinities. Findings were also consistent with gender role stereotypes feminizing relational variables, suggesting that some interpersonal characteristics labeled as positive masculinity in previous research may not represent gendered expectations of men in the broader culture. Implications for the future measurement of positive masculine role norms are discussed.
AB - Researchers using the positive psychology positive masculinity paradigm have advanced several aspects of masculinity that, in theory, represent socialized beliefs linked to healthy personal and relational outcomes in men. However, investigators have yet to explicitly test whether positive masculinity constructs capture broader societal messages dictating positive masculine thoughts, feelings, and behaviors (i.e., male role norms). The present exploratory study created an online survey informed by literature and informal focus groups/interviews to explore how 79 potential positive masculinity attributes were perceived as both positive and socially expected of men. Using Internet and community samples of men and women (N = 1,077), descriptive statistics and paired-sample t tests identified which attributes were rated as positive and statistically expected of men more than they were expected of women. Of the 79 items, all but 3 were strongly rated as positive, 32 were expected more of men, 36 were expected more of women, and 11 were gender neutral. Many definitions of positive masculinity in the extant literature correctly represented thoughts, feelings, and behaviors viewed as positive and socially expected of men, particularly male provider and protector roles. However, some attributes identified as both positive and masculine in the present study may represent moderate expressions of traditional masculinities. Findings were also consistent with gender role stereotypes feminizing relational variables, suggesting that some interpersonal characteristics labeled as positive masculinity in previous research may not represent gendered expectations of men in the broader culture. Implications for the future measurement of positive masculine role norms are discussed.
KW - Expectations
KW - Male role
KW - Norms
KW - Positive masculinity
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85045714806&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85045714806&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1037/men0000160
DO - 10.1037/men0000160
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85045714806
SN - 1524-9220
VL - 20
SP - 12
EP - 22
JO - Psychology of Men and Masculinity
JF - Psychology of Men and Masculinity
IS - 1
ER -