Insights from the san francisco match rank list data: How many interviews does it take to Match?

Menyoli Michael Malafa, Purushottam A. Nagarkar, Jeffrey E. Janis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: For many years, the independent plastic surgery match has been regarded as a competitive process. Applicants expend significant time and resources applying to, and interviewing with, many programs to increase their chance for success. Public data from the San Francisco (SF) Match provide no predictors of success in the Match. Previous survey-based studies have provided some data, but suffer from recall and sampling bias. The purpose of this study was to provide match participants with objective primary-source data that can aid them in making informed decisions with regard to planning their interviews. METHODS: Four years of fully deidentified individual-level and program-level data from the SF Match (2010-2013) were analyzed. Data included number of programs applied to, interview offers, and length of rank lists. For applicants who matched, data included the applicant's rank of program and the program's rank of applicant. RESULTS: During the 4 match years, 434 (86.3%) of 503 applicants received at least 1 interview offer. Of these candidates, 355 (82%) matched. Match rate increased with number of interviews, reaching 96% for those with 5 or more interview offers; 95% of applicants matched within their top 7 choices. On average, applicants matched at number 2.9 on their rank lists. CONCLUSIONS: Number of interview invitations is a strong predictor of success in the independent plastic surgery match, with the "magic number" being 5. Applicants rarely match to programs below number 7 on their rank lists. These data can aid applicants wishing to maximize their potential while minimizing unnecessary expenditures.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)584-588
Number of pages5
JournalAnnals of Plastic Surgery
Volume72
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - 2014

Fingerprint

San Francisco
Interviews
Plastic Surgery
Selection Bias
Information Storage and Retrieval
Health Expenditures
Decision Making

Keywords

  • independent match
  • independent plastic surgery
  • plastic surgery match
  • San Francisco match
  • SF match

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Insights from the san francisco match rank list data : How many interviews does it take to Match? / Malafa, Menyoli Michael; Nagarkar, Purushottam A.; Janis, Jeffrey E.

In: Annals of Plastic Surgery, Vol. 72, No. 5, 2014, p. 584-588.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e9329d957cf1459d982943284cc5a7d8,
title = "Insights from the san francisco match rank list data: How many interviews does it take to Match?",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: For many years, the independent plastic surgery match has been regarded as a competitive process. Applicants expend significant time and resources applying to, and interviewing with, many programs to increase their chance for success. Public data from the San Francisco (SF) Match provide no predictors of success in the Match. Previous survey-based studies have provided some data, but suffer from recall and sampling bias. The purpose of this study was to provide match participants with objective primary-source data that can aid them in making informed decisions with regard to planning their interviews. METHODS: Four years of fully deidentified individual-level and program-level data from the SF Match (2010-2013) were analyzed. Data included number of programs applied to, interview offers, and length of rank lists. For applicants who matched, data included the applicant's rank of program and the program's rank of applicant. RESULTS: During the 4 match years, 434 (86.3{\%}) of 503 applicants received at least 1 interview offer. Of these candidates, 355 (82{\%}) matched. Match rate increased with number of interviews, reaching 96{\%} for those with 5 or more interview offers; 95{\%} of applicants matched within their top 7 choices. On average, applicants matched at number 2.9 on their rank lists. CONCLUSIONS: Number of interview invitations is a strong predictor of success in the independent plastic surgery match, with the {"}magic number{"} being 5. Applicants rarely match to programs below number 7 on their rank lists. These data can aid applicants wishing to maximize their potential while minimizing unnecessary expenditures.",
keywords = "independent match, independent plastic surgery, plastic surgery match, San Francisco match, SF match",
author = "Malafa, {Menyoli Michael} and Nagarkar, {Purushottam A.} and Janis, {Jeffrey E.}",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1097/SAP.0000000000000185",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "72",
pages = "584--588",
journal = "Annals of Plastic Surgery",
issn = "0148-7043",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Insights from the san francisco match rank list data

T2 - How many interviews does it take to Match?

AU - Malafa, Menyoli Michael

AU - Nagarkar, Purushottam A.

AU - Janis, Jeffrey E.

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - BACKGROUND: For many years, the independent plastic surgery match has been regarded as a competitive process. Applicants expend significant time and resources applying to, and interviewing with, many programs to increase their chance for success. Public data from the San Francisco (SF) Match provide no predictors of success in the Match. Previous survey-based studies have provided some data, but suffer from recall and sampling bias. The purpose of this study was to provide match participants with objective primary-source data that can aid them in making informed decisions with regard to planning their interviews. METHODS: Four years of fully deidentified individual-level and program-level data from the SF Match (2010-2013) were analyzed. Data included number of programs applied to, interview offers, and length of rank lists. For applicants who matched, data included the applicant's rank of program and the program's rank of applicant. RESULTS: During the 4 match years, 434 (86.3%) of 503 applicants received at least 1 interview offer. Of these candidates, 355 (82%) matched. Match rate increased with number of interviews, reaching 96% for those with 5 or more interview offers; 95% of applicants matched within their top 7 choices. On average, applicants matched at number 2.9 on their rank lists. CONCLUSIONS: Number of interview invitations is a strong predictor of success in the independent plastic surgery match, with the "magic number" being 5. Applicants rarely match to programs below number 7 on their rank lists. These data can aid applicants wishing to maximize their potential while minimizing unnecessary expenditures.

AB - BACKGROUND: For many years, the independent plastic surgery match has been regarded as a competitive process. Applicants expend significant time and resources applying to, and interviewing with, many programs to increase their chance for success. Public data from the San Francisco (SF) Match provide no predictors of success in the Match. Previous survey-based studies have provided some data, but suffer from recall and sampling bias. The purpose of this study was to provide match participants with objective primary-source data that can aid them in making informed decisions with regard to planning their interviews. METHODS: Four years of fully deidentified individual-level and program-level data from the SF Match (2010-2013) were analyzed. Data included number of programs applied to, interview offers, and length of rank lists. For applicants who matched, data included the applicant's rank of program and the program's rank of applicant. RESULTS: During the 4 match years, 434 (86.3%) of 503 applicants received at least 1 interview offer. Of these candidates, 355 (82%) matched. Match rate increased with number of interviews, reaching 96% for those with 5 or more interview offers; 95% of applicants matched within their top 7 choices. On average, applicants matched at number 2.9 on their rank lists. CONCLUSIONS: Number of interview invitations is a strong predictor of success in the independent plastic surgery match, with the "magic number" being 5. Applicants rarely match to programs below number 7 on their rank lists. These data can aid applicants wishing to maximize their potential while minimizing unnecessary expenditures.

KW - independent match

KW - independent plastic surgery

KW - plastic surgery match

KW - San Francisco match

KW - SF match

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84899472353&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84899472353&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/SAP.0000000000000185

DO - 10.1097/SAP.0000000000000185

M3 - Article

C2 - 24667882

AN - SCOPUS:84899472353

VL - 72

SP - 584

EP - 588

JO - Annals of Plastic Surgery

JF - Annals of Plastic Surgery

SN - 0148-7043

IS - 5

ER -