Inter- and intraobserver variability of radiographic measurements of knee alignment.

O. A. Ilahi, N. R. Kadakia, M. H. Huo

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

To evaluate the variability of radiographic measurement of knee alignment by different observers, as well as repeated measurements by the same observer, standing anteroposterior radiographs of both knees of 36 patients presenting with knee pain were analyzed. Four physicians independently measured the anatomic tibiofemoral angle of both knees for a total of 72 measurements for each observer. These measurements were then repeated 1 month later in a random and blinded fashion. The same handheld goniometer was used for all measurements. The second measurement was within 3.1 degrees of the first measurement 95% of the time, and within 4 degrees 98% of the time. The maximum difference was 6 degrees. Among all four observers, measurements were within 3.7 degrees of each other 95% of the time with a maximum difference of 6 degrees. In addition to radiographic measurement, one physician also performed clinical measurement of knee alignment on these 36 patients using the same handheld goniometer. The clinical measurement was within 5 degrees of the same clinician's radiographic measurement 95% of the time with a maximum difference of 7 degrees. This variability in measuring radiographic alignment should be considered when making decisions on the need for surgical intervention or when evaluating results of procedures that relate to coronal plane alignment of the knee.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)238-242
Number of pages5
JournalThe American journal of knee surgery
Volume14
Issue number4
StatePublished - 2001

Fingerprint

Observer Variation
Knee
Physicians
Decision Making
Pain

Cite this

Inter- and intraobserver variability of radiographic measurements of knee alignment. / Ilahi, O. A.; Kadakia, N. R.; Huo, M. H.

In: The American journal of knee surgery, Vol. 14, No. 4, 2001, p. 238-242.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9771e98d510b44409c2d20b4f2c5f0c7,
title = "Inter- and intraobserver variability of radiographic measurements of knee alignment.",
abstract = "To evaluate the variability of radiographic measurement of knee alignment by different observers, as well as repeated measurements by the same observer, standing anteroposterior radiographs of both knees of 36 patients presenting with knee pain were analyzed. Four physicians independently measured the anatomic tibiofemoral angle of both knees for a total of 72 measurements for each observer. These measurements were then repeated 1 month later in a random and blinded fashion. The same handheld goniometer was used for all measurements. The second measurement was within 3.1 degrees of the first measurement 95{\%} of the time, and within 4 degrees 98{\%} of the time. The maximum difference was 6 degrees. Among all four observers, measurements were within 3.7 degrees of each other 95{\%} of the time with a maximum difference of 6 degrees. In addition to radiographic measurement, one physician also performed clinical measurement of knee alignment on these 36 patients using the same handheld goniometer. The clinical measurement was within 5 degrees of the same clinician's radiographic measurement 95{\%} of the time with a maximum difference of 7 degrees. This variability in measuring radiographic alignment should be considered when making decisions on the need for surgical intervention or when evaluating results of procedures that relate to coronal plane alignment of the knee.",
author = "Ilahi, {O. A.} and Kadakia, {N. R.} and Huo, {M. H.}",
year = "2001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "14",
pages = "238--242",
journal = "Journal of Knee Surgery",
issn = "1538-8506",
publisher = "Thieme Medical Publishers",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Inter- and intraobserver variability of radiographic measurements of knee alignment.

AU - Ilahi, O. A.

AU - Kadakia, N. R.

AU - Huo, M. H.

PY - 2001

Y1 - 2001

N2 - To evaluate the variability of radiographic measurement of knee alignment by different observers, as well as repeated measurements by the same observer, standing anteroposterior radiographs of both knees of 36 patients presenting with knee pain were analyzed. Four physicians independently measured the anatomic tibiofemoral angle of both knees for a total of 72 measurements for each observer. These measurements were then repeated 1 month later in a random and blinded fashion. The same handheld goniometer was used for all measurements. The second measurement was within 3.1 degrees of the first measurement 95% of the time, and within 4 degrees 98% of the time. The maximum difference was 6 degrees. Among all four observers, measurements were within 3.7 degrees of each other 95% of the time with a maximum difference of 6 degrees. In addition to radiographic measurement, one physician also performed clinical measurement of knee alignment on these 36 patients using the same handheld goniometer. The clinical measurement was within 5 degrees of the same clinician's radiographic measurement 95% of the time with a maximum difference of 7 degrees. This variability in measuring radiographic alignment should be considered when making decisions on the need for surgical intervention or when evaluating results of procedures that relate to coronal plane alignment of the knee.

AB - To evaluate the variability of radiographic measurement of knee alignment by different observers, as well as repeated measurements by the same observer, standing anteroposterior radiographs of both knees of 36 patients presenting with knee pain were analyzed. Four physicians independently measured the anatomic tibiofemoral angle of both knees for a total of 72 measurements for each observer. These measurements were then repeated 1 month later in a random and blinded fashion. The same handheld goniometer was used for all measurements. The second measurement was within 3.1 degrees of the first measurement 95% of the time, and within 4 degrees 98% of the time. The maximum difference was 6 degrees. Among all four observers, measurements were within 3.7 degrees of each other 95% of the time with a maximum difference of 6 degrees. In addition to radiographic measurement, one physician also performed clinical measurement of knee alignment on these 36 patients using the same handheld goniometer. The clinical measurement was within 5 degrees of the same clinician's radiographic measurement 95% of the time with a maximum difference of 7 degrees. This variability in measuring radiographic alignment should be considered when making decisions on the need for surgical intervention or when evaluating results of procedures that relate to coronal plane alignment of the knee.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035460557&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0035460557&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 238

EP - 242

JO - Journal of Knee Surgery

JF - Journal of Knee Surgery

SN - 1538-8506

IS - 4

ER -