Interpretive disparity among pathologists in breast sentinel lymph node evaluation

Cory A. Roberts, Peter D. Beitsch, Craig E. Litz, D. Sue Hilton, Gene E. Ewing, Edward Clifford, Walton Taylor, Marc R. Hapke, Armineh Babaian, Imrana Khalid, Joe D. Hall, Guy Lindberg, Kyle Molberg, Hossein Saboorian

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

40 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background Immunohistochemical staining on breast sentinel lymph nodes (SLN) is controversial. Methods Twenty-five SLN cases were reviewed by 10 pathologists (three academic, seven private) including 5 negative by both hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) and immunohistochemistry, 11 micrometastases (<2 mm) negative by H&E but positive by immunohistochemistry, and 8 micrometastases and 1 macrometastasis (>2 mm) positive for both H&E and immunohistochemistry. Answers included "positive," "negative," and "indeterminate" for each slide. Results The mean number of incorrect responses was 6.6 for immunohistochemistry and 5 for H&E. Twelve percent of cases were correct by all 10 pathologists; 80% of positive IHC cases had at least one pathologist score it incorrectly. As tumor cells decrease in number, incorrect responses increase. When tumor cells numbered less than 10, more than 30% of pathologists answered incorrectly. Conclusions As tumor cells decrease in number pathologists' ability to recognize them decreases. We propose adding "indeterminate" to "positive" and "negative" when tumor cells number less than 10.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)324-329
Number of pages6
JournalAmerican Journal of Surgery
Volume186
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 2003

Fingerprint

Breast
Immunohistochemistry
Neoplasms
Neoplasm Micrometastasis
Hematoxylin
Eosine Yellowish-(YS)
Cell Count
Sentinel Lymph Node
Pathologists
Staining and Labeling

Keywords

  • Breast carcinoma
  • Immunohistochemical staining
  • Micrometastases
  • Sentinel lymph node

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Roberts, C. A., Beitsch, P. D., Litz, C. E., Hilton, D. S., Ewing, G. E., Clifford, E., ... Saboorian, H. (2003). Interpretive disparity among pathologists in breast sentinel lymph node evaluation. American Journal of Surgery, 186(4), 324-329. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-9610(03)00268-X

Interpretive disparity among pathologists in breast sentinel lymph node evaluation. / Roberts, Cory A.; Beitsch, Peter D.; Litz, Craig E.; Hilton, D. Sue; Ewing, Gene E.; Clifford, Edward; Taylor, Walton; Hapke, Marc R.; Babaian, Armineh; Khalid, Imrana; Hall, Joe D.; Lindberg, Guy; Molberg, Kyle; Saboorian, Hossein.

In: American Journal of Surgery, Vol. 186, No. 4, 10.2003, p. 324-329.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Roberts, CA, Beitsch, PD, Litz, CE, Hilton, DS, Ewing, GE, Clifford, E, Taylor, W, Hapke, MR, Babaian, A, Khalid, I, Hall, JD, Lindberg, G, Molberg, K & Saboorian, H 2003, 'Interpretive disparity among pathologists in breast sentinel lymph node evaluation', American Journal of Surgery, vol. 186, no. 4, pp. 324-329. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-9610(03)00268-X
Roberts, Cory A. ; Beitsch, Peter D. ; Litz, Craig E. ; Hilton, D. Sue ; Ewing, Gene E. ; Clifford, Edward ; Taylor, Walton ; Hapke, Marc R. ; Babaian, Armineh ; Khalid, Imrana ; Hall, Joe D. ; Lindberg, Guy ; Molberg, Kyle ; Saboorian, Hossein. / Interpretive disparity among pathologists in breast sentinel lymph node evaluation. In: American Journal of Surgery. 2003 ; Vol. 186, No. 4. pp. 324-329.
@article{163aae8b28fe4dedbe5d1a411ab2aaef,
title = "Interpretive disparity among pathologists in breast sentinel lymph node evaluation",
abstract = "Background Immunohistochemical staining on breast sentinel lymph nodes (SLN) is controversial. Methods Twenty-five SLN cases were reviewed by 10 pathologists (three academic, seven private) including 5 negative by both hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) and immunohistochemistry, 11 micrometastases (<2 mm) negative by H&E but positive by immunohistochemistry, and 8 micrometastases and 1 macrometastasis (>2 mm) positive for both H&E and immunohistochemistry. Answers included {"}positive,{"} {"}negative,{"} and {"}indeterminate{"} for each slide. Results The mean number of incorrect responses was 6.6 for immunohistochemistry and 5 for H&E. Twelve percent of cases were correct by all 10 pathologists; 80{\%} of positive IHC cases had at least one pathologist score it incorrectly. As tumor cells decrease in number, incorrect responses increase. When tumor cells numbered less than 10, more than 30{\%} of pathologists answered incorrectly. Conclusions As tumor cells decrease in number pathologists' ability to recognize them decreases. We propose adding {"}indeterminate{"} to {"}positive{"} and {"}negative{"} when tumor cells number less than 10.",
keywords = "Breast carcinoma, Immunohistochemical staining, Micrometastases, Sentinel lymph node",
author = "Roberts, {Cory A.} and Beitsch, {Peter D.} and Litz, {Craig E.} and Hilton, {D. Sue} and Ewing, {Gene E.} and Edward Clifford and Walton Taylor and Hapke, {Marc R.} and Armineh Babaian and Imrana Khalid and Hall, {Joe D.} and Guy Lindberg and Kyle Molberg and Hossein Saboorian",
year = "2003",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1016/S0002-9610(03)00268-X",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "186",
pages = "324--329",
journal = "American Journal of Surgery",
issn = "0002-9610",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Interpretive disparity among pathologists in breast sentinel lymph node evaluation

AU - Roberts, Cory A.

AU - Beitsch, Peter D.

AU - Litz, Craig E.

AU - Hilton, D. Sue

AU - Ewing, Gene E.

AU - Clifford, Edward

AU - Taylor, Walton

AU - Hapke, Marc R.

AU - Babaian, Armineh

AU - Khalid, Imrana

AU - Hall, Joe D.

AU - Lindberg, Guy

AU - Molberg, Kyle

AU - Saboorian, Hossein

PY - 2003/10

Y1 - 2003/10

N2 - Background Immunohistochemical staining on breast sentinel lymph nodes (SLN) is controversial. Methods Twenty-five SLN cases were reviewed by 10 pathologists (three academic, seven private) including 5 negative by both hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) and immunohistochemistry, 11 micrometastases (<2 mm) negative by H&E but positive by immunohistochemistry, and 8 micrometastases and 1 macrometastasis (>2 mm) positive for both H&E and immunohistochemistry. Answers included "positive," "negative," and "indeterminate" for each slide. Results The mean number of incorrect responses was 6.6 for immunohistochemistry and 5 for H&E. Twelve percent of cases were correct by all 10 pathologists; 80% of positive IHC cases had at least one pathologist score it incorrectly. As tumor cells decrease in number, incorrect responses increase. When tumor cells numbered less than 10, more than 30% of pathologists answered incorrectly. Conclusions As tumor cells decrease in number pathologists' ability to recognize them decreases. We propose adding "indeterminate" to "positive" and "negative" when tumor cells number less than 10.

AB - Background Immunohistochemical staining on breast sentinel lymph nodes (SLN) is controversial. Methods Twenty-five SLN cases were reviewed by 10 pathologists (three academic, seven private) including 5 negative by both hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) and immunohistochemistry, 11 micrometastases (<2 mm) negative by H&E but positive by immunohistochemistry, and 8 micrometastases and 1 macrometastasis (>2 mm) positive for both H&E and immunohistochemistry. Answers included "positive," "negative," and "indeterminate" for each slide. Results The mean number of incorrect responses was 6.6 for immunohistochemistry and 5 for H&E. Twelve percent of cases were correct by all 10 pathologists; 80% of positive IHC cases had at least one pathologist score it incorrectly. As tumor cells decrease in number, incorrect responses increase. When tumor cells numbered less than 10, more than 30% of pathologists answered incorrectly. Conclusions As tumor cells decrease in number pathologists' ability to recognize them decreases. We propose adding "indeterminate" to "positive" and "negative" when tumor cells number less than 10.

KW - Breast carcinoma

KW - Immunohistochemical staining

KW - Micrometastases

KW - Sentinel lymph node

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=10744227212&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=10744227212&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/S0002-9610(03)00268-X

DO - 10.1016/S0002-9610(03)00268-X

M3 - Article

C2 - 14553843

AN - SCOPUS:10744227212

VL - 186

SP - 324

EP - 329

JO - American Journal of Surgery

JF - American Journal of Surgery

SN - 0002-9610

IS - 4

ER -