Laparoscopic virtual reality training: Are 30 repetitions enough?

William C. Brunner, James R. Korndorffer, Rafael Sierra, Nader N. Massarweh, J. Bruce Dunne, C. Lillian Yau, Daniel J. Scott

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

83 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Current literature suggests that novices reach a plateau after two to seven trials when training on the MIST VR laparoscopic virtual reality system. We hypothesize that significant benefit may be gained through additional training. Second-year medical students (n = 12) voluntarily enrolled under an IRB-approved protocol for MIST VR training. All subjects completed pre- and posttraining questionnaires and performed 30 repetitions of 12 tasks. Performance data were automatically recorded for each trial. Learning curves for each task were generated by fitting spline curves to the mean overall scores for each repetition. Scores were assessed for plateaus by repeated measures, slope, and best score. On average, subjects completed training in 7.1 h. (range, 5.9-9.2). Two to seven performance plateaus were identified for each of the 12 MIST VR tasks. Initial plateaus were found for all tasks by the 8th repetition; however, ultimate plateaus were not reached until 21-29 repetitions. Overall best score was reached between 20 and 30 repetitions and occurred beyond the ultimate plateau for 9 tasks. These data indicate that a lengthy learning curve exists for novices and may be seen throughout 30 repetitions and possibly beyond. Performance plateaus may not reliably determine training endpoints. We conclude that a significant and variable amount of training may be required to achieve maximal benefit. Neither a predetermined training duration nor an arbitrary number of repetitions may be adequate to ensure laparoscopic proficiency following simulator training. Standards which define performance-based endpoints should be established.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)150-156
Number of pages7
JournalJournal of Surgical Research
Volume122
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2004

Fingerprint

Learning Curve
User-Computer Interface
Research Ethics Committees
Medical Students
Surveys and Questionnaires

Keywords

  • competency
  • laparoscopic skills training
  • laparoscopic surgery
  • learning curve
  • MIST VR
  • surgical education
  • virtual reality

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Brunner, W. C., Korndorffer, J. R., Sierra, R., Massarweh, N. N., Dunne, J. B., Yau, C. L., & Scott, D. J. (2004). Laparoscopic virtual reality training: Are 30 repetitions enough? Journal of Surgical Research, 122(2), 150-156. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2004.08.006

Laparoscopic virtual reality training : Are 30 repetitions enough? / Brunner, William C.; Korndorffer, James R.; Sierra, Rafael; Massarweh, Nader N.; Dunne, J. Bruce; Yau, C. Lillian; Scott, Daniel J.

In: Journal of Surgical Research, Vol. 122, No. 2, 12.2004, p. 150-156.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Brunner, WC, Korndorffer, JR, Sierra, R, Massarweh, NN, Dunne, JB, Yau, CL & Scott, DJ 2004, 'Laparoscopic virtual reality training: Are 30 repetitions enough?', Journal of Surgical Research, vol. 122, no. 2, pp. 150-156. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2004.08.006
Brunner WC, Korndorffer JR, Sierra R, Massarweh NN, Dunne JB, Yau CL et al. Laparoscopic virtual reality training: Are 30 repetitions enough? Journal of Surgical Research. 2004 Dec;122(2):150-156. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2004.08.006
Brunner, William C. ; Korndorffer, James R. ; Sierra, Rafael ; Massarweh, Nader N. ; Dunne, J. Bruce ; Yau, C. Lillian ; Scott, Daniel J. / Laparoscopic virtual reality training : Are 30 repetitions enough?. In: Journal of Surgical Research. 2004 ; Vol. 122, No. 2. pp. 150-156.
@article{c8d186067f734258a0b87943138c4707,
title = "Laparoscopic virtual reality training: Are 30 repetitions enough?",
abstract = "Current literature suggests that novices reach a plateau after two to seven trials when training on the MIST VR laparoscopic virtual reality system. We hypothesize that significant benefit may be gained through additional training. Second-year medical students (n = 12) voluntarily enrolled under an IRB-approved protocol for MIST VR training. All subjects completed pre- and posttraining questionnaires and performed 30 repetitions of 12 tasks. Performance data were automatically recorded for each trial. Learning curves for each task were generated by fitting spline curves to the mean overall scores for each repetition. Scores were assessed for plateaus by repeated measures, slope, and best score. On average, subjects completed training in 7.1 h. (range, 5.9-9.2). Two to seven performance plateaus were identified for each of the 12 MIST VR tasks. Initial plateaus were found for all tasks by the 8th repetition; however, ultimate plateaus were not reached until 21-29 repetitions. Overall best score was reached between 20 and 30 repetitions and occurred beyond the ultimate plateau for 9 tasks. These data indicate that a lengthy learning curve exists for novices and may be seen throughout 30 repetitions and possibly beyond. Performance plateaus may not reliably determine training endpoints. We conclude that a significant and variable amount of training may be required to achieve maximal benefit. Neither a predetermined training duration nor an arbitrary number of repetitions may be adequate to ensure laparoscopic proficiency following simulator training. Standards which define performance-based endpoints should be established.",
keywords = "competency, laparoscopic skills training, laparoscopic surgery, learning curve, MIST VR, surgical education, virtual reality",
author = "Brunner, {William C.} and Korndorffer, {James R.} and Rafael Sierra and Massarweh, {Nader N.} and Dunne, {J. Bruce} and Yau, {C. Lillian} and Scott, {Daniel J.}",
year = "2004",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1016/j.jss.2004.08.006",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "122",
pages = "150--156",
journal = "Journal of Surgical Research",
issn = "0022-4804",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Laparoscopic virtual reality training

T2 - Are 30 repetitions enough?

AU - Brunner, William C.

AU - Korndorffer, James R.

AU - Sierra, Rafael

AU - Massarweh, Nader N.

AU - Dunne, J. Bruce

AU - Yau, C. Lillian

AU - Scott, Daniel J.

PY - 2004/12

Y1 - 2004/12

N2 - Current literature suggests that novices reach a plateau after two to seven trials when training on the MIST VR laparoscopic virtual reality system. We hypothesize that significant benefit may be gained through additional training. Second-year medical students (n = 12) voluntarily enrolled under an IRB-approved protocol for MIST VR training. All subjects completed pre- and posttraining questionnaires and performed 30 repetitions of 12 tasks. Performance data were automatically recorded for each trial. Learning curves for each task were generated by fitting spline curves to the mean overall scores for each repetition. Scores were assessed for plateaus by repeated measures, slope, and best score. On average, subjects completed training in 7.1 h. (range, 5.9-9.2). Two to seven performance plateaus were identified for each of the 12 MIST VR tasks. Initial plateaus were found for all tasks by the 8th repetition; however, ultimate plateaus were not reached until 21-29 repetitions. Overall best score was reached between 20 and 30 repetitions and occurred beyond the ultimate plateau for 9 tasks. These data indicate that a lengthy learning curve exists for novices and may be seen throughout 30 repetitions and possibly beyond. Performance plateaus may not reliably determine training endpoints. We conclude that a significant and variable amount of training may be required to achieve maximal benefit. Neither a predetermined training duration nor an arbitrary number of repetitions may be adequate to ensure laparoscopic proficiency following simulator training. Standards which define performance-based endpoints should be established.

AB - Current literature suggests that novices reach a plateau after two to seven trials when training on the MIST VR laparoscopic virtual reality system. We hypothesize that significant benefit may be gained through additional training. Second-year medical students (n = 12) voluntarily enrolled under an IRB-approved protocol for MIST VR training. All subjects completed pre- and posttraining questionnaires and performed 30 repetitions of 12 tasks. Performance data were automatically recorded for each trial. Learning curves for each task were generated by fitting spline curves to the mean overall scores for each repetition. Scores were assessed for plateaus by repeated measures, slope, and best score. On average, subjects completed training in 7.1 h. (range, 5.9-9.2). Two to seven performance plateaus were identified for each of the 12 MIST VR tasks. Initial plateaus were found for all tasks by the 8th repetition; however, ultimate plateaus were not reached until 21-29 repetitions. Overall best score was reached between 20 and 30 repetitions and occurred beyond the ultimate plateau for 9 tasks. These data indicate that a lengthy learning curve exists for novices and may be seen throughout 30 repetitions and possibly beyond. Performance plateaus may not reliably determine training endpoints. We conclude that a significant and variable amount of training may be required to achieve maximal benefit. Neither a predetermined training duration nor an arbitrary number of repetitions may be adequate to ensure laparoscopic proficiency following simulator training. Standards which define performance-based endpoints should be established.

KW - competency

KW - laparoscopic skills training

KW - laparoscopic surgery

KW - learning curve

KW - MIST VR

KW - surgical education

KW - virtual reality

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=8844249468&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=8844249468&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jss.2004.08.006

DO - 10.1016/j.jss.2004.08.006

M3 - Article

C2 - 15555611

AN - SCOPUS:8844249468

VL - 122

SP - 150

EP - 156

JO - Journal of Surgical Research

JF - Journal of Surgical Research

SN - 0022-4804

IS - 2

ER -