Spatio-temporal analysis of auditory cortex activation as detected with silent event related fMRI

William F. Christensen, F. Zerrin Yetkin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Functional magnetic resonance imaging (f MRI) allows neuroscientists to assess brain function by evaluating haemodynamic activity (blood flow) when a stimulus is present or absent. In clinical practice, the hearing levels of individuals are determined using an audiometer that allows presentation of a pure-tone of specific intensity and frequency. Functional images of the auditory nervous system have been obtained using stimuli such as pure-tone, speech, noise, etc. However, the observed activation evoked by the stimulus is confounded with the neuronal response evoked by scanner noise generated during imaging. Hence, researchers have been developing fMRI techniques to overcome the inadvertent effect of scanner noise on fMRI studies of the auditory cortex. Silent event related fMRI is a recently reported fMRI technique diminishing the confounding effects of background scanner noise. A drawback of sfMRI is that it requires long acquisition times (30-40 min) to achieve statistically significant activation. An additional complication associated with all fMRI data is that measurements obtained at consecutive times tend to exhibit substantial temporal correlation. Such correlation structure complicates the identification of brain locations (voxels) demonstrating statistically significant activation. We propose an approach for detecting activation with high statistical power and low false-positive rate. To accomplish these goals of high power and low type I error rate in sfMRI with shorter acquisition times, we describe a statistical model that accounts for the spatial and temporal correlation structure of the haemodynamic response. Temporal dependence within each voxel's measurements is modelled, and a regional measurement-error-free kriging predictor is used to combine information from neighbouring voxels when assessing voxel activation. Instead of simply applying a post hoc smoothing to the voxelwise test statistics (e.g. t statistics), we attempt to make optimal use of information in the locality of each voxel when estimating the voxel's mean, variance, and temporal dependence parameters. The primary advantage to this spatial modelling approach is that the degree to which voxel parameters are smoothed is driven by the data. Thus, we are not subjectively smoothing noisy data, but objectively estimating the noise-free version of the spatial processes associated with the response. The resulting voxel activation maps exhibit substantially more spatial continuity than other currently used approaches, while exhibiting desirable inferential properties including a lower false-positive rate and high power for detection of activated regions. Minimal computational resources are necessary to carry out the approach, which yielded voxel activation maps for our experiment in only minutes.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)2539-2556
Number of pages18
JournalStatistics in Medicine
Volume24
Issue number16
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 30 2005

Fingerprint

Spatio-Temporal Analysis
Auditory Cortex
Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Voxel
Cortex
Activation
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Noise
Scanner
Temporal Correlation
Correlation Structure
Hemodynamics
False Positive
High Power
Smoothing
Spatial Analysis
Brain
Statistical Models
Spatial Modeling
Spatial Process

Keywords

  • Magnetic resonance
  • Measurement-error-free kriging
  • Neuroimaging
  • Spatial correlation
  • Voxel activation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Epidemiology

Cite this

Spatio-temporal analysis of auditory cortex activation as detected with silent event related fMRI. / Christensen, William F.; Yetkin, F. Zerrin.

In: Statistics in Medicine, Vol. 24, No. 16, 30.08.2005, p. 2539-2556.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{22212e4fa55942d984ac470988fc50d2,
title = "Spatio-temporal analysis of auditory cortex activation as detected with silent event related fMRI",
abstract = "Functional magnetic resonance imaging (f MRI) allows neuroscientists to assess brain function by evaluating haemodynamic activity (blood flow) when a stimulus is present or absent. In clinical practice, the hearing levels of individuals are determined using an audiometer that allows presentation of a pure-tone of specific intensity and frequency. Functional images of the auditory nervous system have been obtained using stimuli such as pure-tone, speech, noise, etc. However, the observed activation evoked by the stimulus is confounded with the neuronal response evoked by scanner noise generated during imaging. Hence, researchers have been developing fMRI techniques to overcome the inadvertent effect of scanner noise on fMRI studies of the auditory cortex. Silent event related fMRI is a recently reported fMRI technique diminishing the confounding effects of background scanner noise. A drawback of sfMRI is that it requires long acquisition times (30-40 min) to achieve statistically significant activation. An additional complication associated with all fMRI data is that measurements obtained at consecutive times tend to exhibit substantial temporal correlation. Such correlation structure complicates the identification of brain locations (voxels) demonstrating statistically significant activation. We propose an approach for detecting activation with high statistical power and low false-positive rate. To accomplish these goals of high power and low type I error rate in sfMRI with shorter acquisition times, we describe a statistical model that accounts for the spatial and temporal correlation structure of the haemodynamic response. Temporal dependence within each voxel's measurements is modelled, and a regional measurement-error-free kriging predictor is used to combine information from neighbouring voxels when assessing voxel activation. Instead of simply applying a post hoc smoothing to the voxelwise test statistics (e.g. t statistics), we attempt to make optimal use of information in the locality of each voxel when estimating the voxel's mean, variance, and temporal dependence parameters. The primary advantage to this spatial modelling approach is that the degree to which voxel parameters are smoothed is driven by the data. Thus, we are not subjectively smoothing noisy data, but objectively estimating the noise-free version of the spatial processes associated with the response. The resulting voxel activation maps exhibit substantially more spatial continuity than other currently used approaches, while exhibiting desirable inferential properties including a lower false-positive rate and high power for detection of activated regions. Minimal computational resources are necessary to carry out the approach, which yielded voxel activation maps for our experiment in only minutes.",
keywords = "Magnetic resonance, Measurement-error-free kriging, Neuroimaging, Spatial correlation, Voxel activation",
author = "Christensen, {William F.} and Yetkin, {F. Zerrin}",
year = "2005",
month = "8",
day = "30",
doi = "10.1002/sim.2111",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "24",
pages = "2539--2556",
journal = "Statistics in Medicine",
issn = "0277-6715",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "16",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spatio-temporal analysis of auditory cortex activation as detected with silent event related fMRI

AU - Christensen, William F.

AU - Yetkin, F. Zerrin

PY - 2005/8/30

Y1 - 2005/8/30

N2 - Functional magnetic resonance imaging (f MRI) allows neuroscientists to assess brain function by evaluating haemodynamic activity (blood flow) when a stimulus is present or absent. In clinical practice, the hearing levels of individuals are determined using an audiometer that allows presentation of a pure-tone of specific intensity and frequency. Functional images of the auditory nervous system have been obtained using stimuli such as pure-tone, speech, noise, etc. However, the observed activation evoked by the stimulus is confounded with the neuronal response evoked by scanner noise generated during imaging. Hence, researchers have been developing fMRI techniques to overcome the inadvertent effect of scanner noise on fMRI studies of the auditory cortex. Silent event related fMRI is a recently reported fMRI technique diminishing the confounding effects of background scanner noise. A drawback of sfMRI is that it requires long acquisition times (30-40 min) to achieve statistically significant activation. An additional complication associated with all fMRI data is that measurements obtained at consecutive times tend to exhibit substantial temporal correlation. Such correlation structure complicates the identification of brain locations (voxels) demonstrating statistically significant activation. We propose an approach for detecting activation with high statistical power and low false-positive rate. To accomplish these goals of high power and low type I error rate in sfMRI with shorter acquisition times, we describe a statistical model that accounts for the spatial and temporal correlation structure of the haemodynamic response. Temporal dependence within each voxel's measurements is modelled, and a regional measurement-error-free kriging predictor is used to combine information from neighbouring voxels when assessing voxel activation. Instead of simply applying a post hoc smoothing to the voxelwise test statistics (e.g. t statistics), we attempt to make optimal use of information in the locality of each voxel when estimating the voxel's mean, variance, and temporal dependence parameters. The primary advantage to this spatial modelling approach is that the degree to which voxel parameters are smoothed is driven by the data. Thus, we are not subjectively smoothing noisy data, but objectively estimating the noise-free version of the spatial processes associated with the response. The resulting voxel activation maps exhibit substantially more spatial continuity than other currently used approaches, while exhibiting desirable inferential properties including a lower false-positive rate and high power for detection of activated regions. Minimal computational resources are necessary to carry out the approach, which yielded voxel activation maps for our experiment in only minutes.

AB - Functional magnetic resonance imaging (f MRI) allows neuroscientists to assess brain function by evaluating haemodynamic activity (blood flow) when a stimulus is present or absent. In clinical practice, the hearing levels of individuals are determined using an audiometer that allows presentation of a pure-tone of specific intensity and frequency. Functional images of the auditory nervous system have been obtained using stimuli such as pure-tone, speech, noise, etc. However, the observed activation evoked by the stimulus is confounded with the neuronal response evoked by scanner noise generated during imaging. Hence, researchers have been developing fMRI techniques to overcome the inadvertent effect of scanner noise on fMRI studies of the auditory cortex. Silent event related fMRI is a recently reported fMRI technique diminishing the confounding effects of background scanner noise. A drawback of sfMRI is that it requires long acquisition times (30-40 min) to achieve statistically significant activation. An additional complication associated with all fMRI data is that measurements obtained at consecutive times tend to exhibit substantial temporal correlation. Such correlation structure complicates the identification of brain locations (voxels) demonstrating statistically significant activation. We propose an approach for detecting activation with high statistical power and low false-positive rate. To accomplish these goals of high power and low type I error rate in sfMRI with shorter acquisition times, we describe a statistical model that accounts for the spatial and temporal correlation structure of the haemodynamic response. Temporal dependence within each voxel's measurements is modelled, and a regional measurement-error-free kriging predictor is used to combine information from neighbouring voxels when assessing voxel activation. Instead of simply applying a post hoc smoothing to the voxelwise test statistics (e.g. t statistics), we attempt to make optimal use of information in the locality of each voxel when estimating the voxel's mean, variance, and temporal dependence parameters. The primary advantage to this spatial modelling approach is that the degree to which voxel parameters are smoothed is driven by the data. Thus, we are not subjectively smoothing noisy data, but objectively estimating the noise-free version of the spatial processes associated with the response. The resulting voxel activation maps exhibit substantially more spatial continuity than other currently used approaches, while exhibiting desirable inferential properties including a lower false-positive rate and high power for detection of activated regions. Minimal computational resources are necessary to carry out the approach, which yielded voxel activation maps for our experiment in only minutes.

KW - Magnetic resonance

KW - Measurement-error-free kriging

KW - Neuroimaging

KW - Spatial correlation

KW - Voxel activation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=23244466831&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=23244466831&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/sim.2111

DO - 10.1002/sim.2111

M3 - Article

C2 - 15909287

AN - SCOPUS:23244466831

VL - 24

SP - 2539

EP - 2556

JO - Statistics in Medicine

JF - Statistics in Medicine

SN - 0277-6715

IS - 16

ER -