Urinary cytology has a poor performance for predicting invasive or high-grade upper-tract urothelial carcinoma

Jamie Messer, Shahrokh F. Shariat, James C. Brien, Michael P. Herman, Casey K. Ng, Douglas S. Scherr, Benjamin Scoll, Robert G. Uzzo, Mark Wille, Scott E. Eggener, Gary Steinberg, John D. Terrell, Steven M. Lucas, Yair Lotan, Stephen A. Boorjian, Jay D. Raman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

105 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

OBJECTIVE To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of urine cytology for detecting aggressive disease in a multi-institutional cohort of patients undergoing extirpative surgery for upper-tract urothelial carcinoma (UTUC). METHODS We reviewed the records of 326 patients with urinary cytology data who underwent a radical nephroureterectomy or distal ureterectomy without concurrent or previous bladder cancer. We assessed the association of cytology (positive, negative and atypical) with final pathology. Sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) of a positive (± atypical) cytology for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC was calculated. RESULTS On final pathology, 53% of patients had non-muscle invasive disease (pTa, pTis, pT1) and 47% had invasive disease (≥pT2). Low-grade and high-grade cancers were present in 33% and 67% of patients, respectively. Positive, atypical and negative urine cytology was noted in 40%, 40% and 20% of cases. Positive urinary cytology had sensitivity and PPV of 56% and 54% for high-grade and 62% and 44% for muscle-invasive UTUC. Inclusion of atypical cytology with positive cytology improved the sensitivity and PPV for high-grade (74% and 63%) and muscle-invasive (77% and 45%) UTUC. Restricting analysis to patients with selective ureteral cytologies further improved the diagnostic accuracy when compared with bladder specimens (PPV > 85% for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC). CONCLUSIONS In this cohort of patients with UTUC treated with radical surgery, urine cytology in isolation lacked performance characteristics to accurately predict muscle-invasive or high-grade disease. Improved surrogate markers for pathological grade and stage are necessary, particularly when considering endoscopic modalities for UTUC.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)701-705
Number of pages5
JournalBJU International
Volume108
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 2011

Fingerprint

Cell Biology
Carcinoma
Muscles
Urine
Pathology
Urinary Bladder Neoplasms
Urinary Bladder
Biomarkers

Keywords

  • cytology
  • radical nephroureterectomy
  • transitional cell carcinoma
  • urothelial carcinoma

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Urology

Cite this

Messer, J., Shariat, S. F., Brien, J. C., Herman, M. P., Ng, C. K., Scherr, D. S., ... Raman, J. D. (2011). Urinary cytology has a poor performance for predicting invasive or high-grade upper-tract urothelial carcinoma. BJU International, 108(5), 701-705. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1464-410X.2010.09899.x

Urinary cytology has a poor performance for predicting invasive or high-grade upper-tract urothelial carcinoma. / Messer, Jamie; Shariat, Shahrokh F.; Brien, James C.; Herman, Michael P.; Ng, Casey K.; Scherr, Douglas S.; Scoll, Benjamin; Uzzo, Robert G.; Wille, Mark; Eggener, Scott E.; Steinberg, Gary; Terrell, John D.; Lucas, Steven M.; Lotan, Yair; Boorjian, Stephen A.; Raman, Jay D.

In: BJU International, Vol. 108, No. 5, 09.2011, p. 701-705.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Messer, J, Shariat, SF, Brien, JC, Herman, MP, Ng, CK, Scherr, DS, Scoll, B, Uzzo, RG, Wille, M, Eggener, SE, Steinberg, G, Terrell, JD, Lucas, SM, Lotan, Y, Boorjian, SA & Raman, JD 2011, 'Urinary cytology has a poor performance for predicting invasive or high-grade upper-tract urothelial carcinoma', BJU International, vol. 108, no. 5, pp. 701-705. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1464-410X.2010.09899.x
Messer, Jamie ; Shariat, Shahrokh F. ; Brien, James C. ; Herman, Michael P. ; Ng, Casey K. ; Scherr, Douglas S. ; Scoll, Benjamin ; Uzzo, Robert G. ; Wille, Mark ; Eggener, Scott E. ; Steinberg, Gary ; Terrell, John D. ; Lucas, Steven M. ; Lotan, Yair ; Boorjian, Stephen A. ; Raman, Jay D. / Urinary cytology has a poor performance for predicting invasive or high-grade upper-tract urothelial carcinoma. In: BJU International. 2011 ; Vol. 108, No. 5. pp. 701-705.
@article{ae4e990ae4294aee9aad60e66613dbf0,
title = "Urinary cytology has a poor performance for predicting invasive or high-grade upper-tract urothelial carcinoma",
abstract = "OBJECTIVE To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of urine cytology for detecting aggressive disease in a multi-institutional cohort of patients undergoing extirpative surgery for upper-tract urothelial carcinoma (UTUC). METHODS We reviewed the records of 326 patients with urinary cytology data who underwent a radical nephroureterectomy or distal ureterectomy without concurrent or previous bladder cancer. We assessed the association of cytology (positive, negative and atypical) with final pathology. Sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) of a positive (± atypical) cytology for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC was calculated. RESULTS On final pathology, 53{\%} of patients had non-muscle invasive disease (pTa, pTis, pT1) and 47{\%} had invasive disease (≥pT2). Low-grade and high-grade cancers were present in 33{\%} and 67{\%} of patients, respectively. Positive, atypical and negative urine cytology was noted in 40{\%}, 40{\%} and 20{\%} of cases. Positive urinary cytology had sensitivity and PPV of 56{\%} and 54{\%} for high-grade and 62{\%} and 44{\%} for muscle-invasive UTUC. Inclusion of atypical cytology with positive cytology improved the sensitivity and PPV for high-grade (74{\%} and 63{\%}) and muscle-invasive (77{\%} and 45{\%}) UTUC. Restricting analysis to patients with selective ureteral cytologies further improved the diagnostic accuracy when compared with bladder specimens (PPV > 85{\%} for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC). CONCLUSIONS In this cohort of patients with UTUC treated with radical surgery, urine cytology in isolation lacked performance characteristics to accurately predict muscle-invasive or high-grade disease. Improved surrogate markers for pathological grade and stage are necessary, particularly when considering endoscopic modalities for UTUC.",
keywords = "cytology, radical nephroureterectomy, transitional cell carcinoma, urothelial carcinoma",
author = "Jamie Messer and Shariat, {Shahrokh F.} and Brien, {James C.} and Herman, {Michael P.} and Ng, {Casey K.} and Scherr, {Douglas S.} and Benjamin Scoll and Uzzo, {Robert G.} and Mark Wille and Eggener, {Scott E.} and Gary Steinberg and Terrell, {John D.} and Lucas, {Steven M.} and Yair Lotan and Boorjian, {Stephen A.} and Raman, {Jay D.}",
year = "2011",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1111/j.1464-410X.2010.09899.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "108",
pages = "701--705",
journal = "BJU International",
issn = "1464-4096",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Urinary cytology has a poor performance for predicting invasive or high-grade upper-tract urothelial carcinoma

AU - Messer, Jamie

AU - Shariat, Shahrokh F.

AU - Brien, James C.

AU - Herman, Michael P.

AU - Ng, Casey K.

AU - Scherr, Douglas S.

AU - Scoll, Benjamin

AU - Uzzo, Robert G.

AU - Wille, Mark

AU - Eggener, Scott E.

AU - Steinberg, Gary

AU - Terrell, John D.

AU - Lucas, Steven M.

AU - Lotan, Yair

AU - Boorjian, Stephen A.

AU - Raman, Jay D.

PY - 2011/9

Y1 - 2011/9

N2 - OBJECTIVE To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of urine cytology for detecting aggressive disease in a multi-institutional cohort of patients undergoing extirpative surgery for upper-tract urothelial carcinoma (UTUC). METHODS We reviewed the records of 326 patients with urinary cytology data who underwent a radical nephroureterectomy or distal ureterectomy without concurrent or previous bladder cancer. We assessed the association of cytology (positive, negative and atypical) with final pathology. Sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) of a positive (± atypical) cytology for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC was calculated. RESULTS On final pathology, 53% of patients had non-muscle invasive disease (pTa, pTis, pT1) and 47% had invasive disease (≥pT2). Low-grade and high-grade cancers were present in 33% and 67% of patients, respectively. Positive, atypical and negative urine cytology was noted in 40%, 40% and 20% of cases. Positive urinary cytology had sensitivity and PPV of 56% and 54% for high-grade and 62% and 44% for muscle-invasive UTUC. Inclusion of atypical cytology with positive cytology improved the sensitivity and PPV for high-grade (74% and 63%) and muscle-invasive (77% and 45%) UTUC. Restricting analysis to patients with selective ureteral cytologies further improved the diagnostic accuracy when compared with bladder specimens (PPV > 85% for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC). CONCLUSIONS In this cohort of patients with UTUC treated with radical surgery, urine cytology in isolation lacked performance characteristics to accurately predict muscle-invasive or high-grade disease. Improved surrogate markers for pathological grade and stage are necessary, particularly when considering endoscopic modalities for UTUC.

AB - OBJECTIVE To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of urine cytology for detecting aggressive disease in a multi-institutional cohort of patients undergoing extirpative surgery for upper-tract urothelial carcinoma (UTUC). METHODS We reviewed the records of 326 patients with urinary cytology data who underwent a radical nephroureterectomy or distal ureterectomy without concurrent or previous bladder cancer. We assessed the association of cytology (positive, negative and atypical) with final pathology. Sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) of a positive (± atypical) cytology for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC was calculated. RESULTS On final pathology, 53% of patients had non-muscle invasive disease (pTa, pTis, pT1) and 47% had invasive disease (≥pT2). Low-grade and high-grade cancers were present in 33% and 67% of patients, respectively. Positive, atypical and negative urine cytology was noted in 40%, 40% and 20% of cases. Positive urinary cytology had sensitivity and PPV of 56% and 54% for high-grade and 62% and 44% for muscle-invasive UTUC. Inclusion of atypical cytology with positive cytology improved the sensitivity and PPV for high-grade (74% and 63%) and muscle-invasive (77% and 45%) UTUC. Restricting analysis to patients with selective ureteral cytologies further improved the diagnostic accuracy when compared with bladder specimens (PPV > 85% for high-grade and muscle-invasive UTUC). CONCLUSIONS In this cohort of patients with UTUC treated with radical surgery, urine cytology in isolation lacked performance characteristics to accurately predict muscle-invasive or high-grade disease. Improved surrogate markers for pathological grade and stage are necessary, particularly when considering endoscopic modalities for UTUC.

KW - cytology

KW - radical nephroureterectomy

KW - transitional cell carcinoma

KW - urothelial carcinoma

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=80052037243&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=80052037243&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1464-410X.2010.09899.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1464-410X.2010.09899.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 21320275

AN - SCOPUS:80052037243

VL - 108

SP - 701

EP - 705

JO - BJU International

JF - BJU International

SN - 1464-4096

IS - 5

ER -